Chart
Best Wood for Spoon Carving: A Species-by-Species Chart
Published
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
New to Prime? Try Prime free for fast, free shipping on eligible items.
Short answer
The usual woods for a spoon you eat with are closed-grain hardwoods carved green: birch (910 to 1,210 lbf), cherry (950), maple (700 to 1,450), walnut (1,010), alder (590), beech, apple and pear. Basswood (410) and yellow poplar (540) carve easily but dent and wear, so they suit practice or decorative spoons. Sources advise against oak, ash, pine and cedar.
Gear for this job
All 7 picks comparedABuff spoon blanks, walnut and basswood, 12 pieces
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonBeaverCraft BB2 spoon blanks, 4 woods, 4 pieces
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonCo-link beech and walnut spoon blanks, 4 pieces
See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon

Most people arrive here with one species in mind: a birch branch from the yard, a poplar board, a basswood blank from a kit. The chart answers yes or no for each and says why. Two things decide the verdict. The first is grain: fine and closed, or ring-porous with large open pores. The second is hardness, which sets how the finished spoon wears. Hardness figures are for dry wood. Green wood of the same species cuts far more easily, which is why spoon carvers work it fresh.
Spoon carving wood chart: 15 species
One row per species: the usual spoon woods first, then the soft practice woods, then the woods sources advise against. Hardness is the Janka figure for dry wood from the Wood Database. The notes come from the Wood Database and from Sylva Spoon's species guide. The last column follows this site's stated rule for the spoon column of its wood chart. It is not a test result.
| Wood | Janka, lbf | Grain | How it carves green | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Birch (paper, silver) | 910, 1,210 | Fine, closed, diffuse-porous | A standard green spoon wood. Easy with hand tools. Wild grain can tear | Eating and cooking spoons |
| Black cherry | 950 | Closed | Among the best woods for workability. Heartwood more brittle than sapwood | Eating spoons, a favorite |
| Soft maple (silver, red) | 700, 950 | Fine, closed | Much easier than hard maple. Rippled grain can leave a rough surface | Eating spoons |
| Hard maple | 1,450 | Fine, closed | Heavy work even when green | Durable eating and cooking spoons |
| Black walnut | 1,010 | Semi-ring-porous, straight | Carves smoothly. Strong smell and a bit of flavor while still green | Eating spoons |
| Red alder | 590 | Fine, even | Very easy with hand tools. A common green spoon wood | First eating spoon |
| American beech | 1,300 | Closed | Hard. Carve it green | Eating and cooking spoons |
| Pear | 1,660 | Fine, even, no visible pores | Easy to work for its hardness | Eating spoons |
| Apple | 1,730 | Closed | Dense and hard. Knots and twisted grain, small pieces | Small eating spoons |
| Basswood | 410 | Fine, even, diffuse-porous | Carves very easily. Usually sold dry | Practice or decorative: dents and wears |
| Yellow poplar | 540 | Straight, diffuse-porous | Very easy to work. Can leave fuzzy surfaces | Practice: soft for daily use |
| Oak (red, white) | 1,220 to 1,360 | Ring-porous, large open pores | Hard | Sources say avoid for spoons |
| White ash | 1,320 | Ring-porous, large open pores | Hard | Sources say avoid for spoons |
| Pine (eastern white) | 380 | Softwood, resin | Soft | Sources say avoid for spoons |
| Cedar (western red, eastern red) | 350, 900 | Softwood, strong aroma | Soft, dents easily | Not a utensil wood |
How to read the chart
Janka hardness is the force in pounds-force needed to press a 0.444 inch steel ball halfway into dry wood. Lower cuts easier. The numbers rank how the finished, dried spoon resists dents. They do not describe the effort of carving green, which is far lower for every species here.
The verdict rule is short. A closed-grain hardwood from about 590 lbf up is a yes for a spoon in daily use. A hardwood under 590 lbf carves easily but dents and wears, so it is a maybe. Softwoods and ring-porous hardwoods with large open pores are a no. The rule is the usual hobby consensus applied to hardness and grain. The same verdicts, with whittling, chip carving and relief columns, are in the wood for carving chart.
Is birch or maple good for spoon carving?
Birch is good for spoon carving, and it is one of the standard green spoon woods. Paper birch is 910 lbf dry with a fine, even texture and no characteristic odor, according to the Wood Database. Sylva Spoon describes it as easy to carve with hand tools and still durable in the kitchen. Silver birch and yellow birch are harder, at 1,210 and 1,260 lbf. Watch for wild grain around knots, which can tear.
Maple is good too, carved green. The soft maples are the easier start: silver maple at 700 lbf and red maple at 950. Hard maple is 1,450 lbf and heavy work even when fresh, but it makes a durable spoon. Cherry sits between them at 950 lbf and is a favorite for spoons.
Is basswood or poplar good for spoon carving?
Basswood is good for learning the cuts and poor for a spoon in daily use. At 410 lbf it is the standard carving wood: fine, even and easy on the knife. The same softness means the bowl rim dents and the surface wears. Blanks in kits and packs are often basswood for that reason: it cuts easily even dry. Treat the result as a practice or decorative spoon.
Yellow poplar is a step harder at 540 lbf and still under the 590 line. It is very easy to work and can leave fuzzy surfaces, so keep the edge stropped. It is soft for a spoon in daily use. The same goes for aspen and cottonwood, which are also sold as poplar.
Is cedar, pine, oak or ash good for spoon carving?
These are the woods sources advise against for spoons. Sylva Spoon's guide by Thomas Bartlett says to avoid softwoods, naming pines and spruces, and ring-porous species, naming oaks and ashes, and states that diffuse-porous wood tends to work best. This site's chart follows the same practice: softwoods are a no for resin or strong smell, and oak, ash, hickory and catalpa are a no for their large open pores.
Cedar is soft enough to cut, but western red cedar dents and scratches very easily and all the cedars are strongly aromatic. Oak and ash are also hard: 1,220 to 1,360 lbf. These verdicts are about pores, smell and common practice only. This page makes no health or food-safety claim about any wood. For dust and allergy questions, see the Wood Database chart of wood allergies and toxicity, listed in the sources.
Where to get spoon wood and how to keep it green
The best spoon wood is a freshly cut branch or log of a species in the top half of the chart. Coat the log ends with end sealer or latex paint right away, because cracks start at the end grain. Between sessions keep split blanks in a sealed plastic bag or in the freezer. Bought blanks are normally dry and cut harder. The trade-off is explained in green wood vs dry wood for spoon carving.
A thin carved spoon dries in about 2 to 3 days. Sources range from a couple of days to two weeks. Then come the final cuts and the oil. The whole sequence is in how to carve a spoon, and the oils are compared in food-safe finish for carved spoons.
Quick answers
One line per species people ask about. Hardness figures are for dry wood. Every one of these woods cuts far more easily green.
- Is basswood good for spoon carving? For practice and decorative spoons, yes. At 410 lbf it dents and wears in daily use.
- Is birch good for spoon carving? Yes. It is a standard green spoon wood, 910 lbf for paper birch and 1,210 for silver birch.
- Is maple good for spoon carving? Yes, carved green. Soft maples (700 to 950 lbf) are easier than hard maple (1,450 lbf).
- Is poplar good for spoon carving? It carves easily but at 540 lbf it is soft for a spoon in daily use. Good for practice.
- Is cedar good for spoon carving? No. It is a strongly aromatic softwood that dents easily, and sources advise against softwoods for spoons.
Use this chart
Print it, save the image version, or put it on your own site or forum post with the code below. The code keeps a link back to this page as the source.
Embed code
<a href="https://carvingbench.com/blog/wood-for-spoon-carving"><img src="https://carvingbench.com/charts/wood-for-spoon-carving/image.png" alt="Best Wood for Spoon Carving: A Species-by-Species Chart" width="600" loading="lazy"></a> <p>Source: <a href="https://carvingbench.com/blog/wood-for-spoon-carving">Best Wood for Spoon Carving: A Species-by-Species Chart</a>, Carving Bench</p>
What you need for this
- See price on AmazonAmazon
ABuff spoon blanks, walnut and basswood, 12 pieces
From Best Spoon Carving Blanks: Pre-Cut Blanks by Wood and Size
- See price on AmazonAmazon
BeaverCraft DIY04 spoon carving kit with blank
From Best Spoon Carving Kits: What Is in the Box and What Is Missing
- See price on AmazonAmazon
BeaverCraft SK1 hook knife, right-handed
From Best Spoon Carving Hook Knives: Right-Hand, Left-Hand and Double-Edge