Comparison

Green Wood vs Dry Wood for Spoon Carving: Which to Use

Published

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
New to Prime? Try Prime free for fast, free shipping on eligible items.

Gear for this job

All 7 picks compared

This page is for two readers: one with a fresh branch or log and one with a store-bought dry blank. Both will make a spoon. What changes is the effort, how often the edge needs the strop, and where the risk of cracks sits. Three things decide how the wood cuts: how much water is still in it, how hard the species is, and how sharp the knife is. The hardness figures on this site are for dry wood at 12% moisture. Green wood of the same species cuts far more easily than those figures suggest.

Green wood vs dry wood for spoons, side by side

Green means freshly cut and still wet. Dry means a kiln-dried or long-stored blank. The table sums up standard spoon carving practice and the two spoon carvers listed under Sources.

Can you carve spoons from green wood?

Yes. It is the normal way. Spoon carvers rough out the shape and hollow the bowl while the wood is wet, leave a little extra wood everywhere, let the spoon dry, then come back for the final cuts. David Fisher, who documents his spoon stages, removes all the wood he can while green but leaves some for cleanup, because final cuts in dry wood come out cleaner and more polished.

Split the log through the center and work from one half so the pith, the soft core of the branch, is not in the spoon. Anne of All Trades notes that a spoon with the pith left in is much more prone to warping and cracking as it dries. For species, closed-grain hardwoods such as birch, cherry, maple and walnut are the usual picks: see the best wood for spoon carving.

Choose green wood when

Green wood is the better choice whenever fresh wood is within reach and the spoon can wait a few days between shaping and finishing.

  • You have a freshly cut branch or log of a closed-grain hardwood: birch, cherry, maple, walnut, alder, beech, apple or pear.
  • The wood is a hard species. Hard maple is 1,450 lbf when dry and heavy work even green, so carve it green.
  • You are learning the hook knife. Hollowing a bowl in wet wood takes much less force than in dry wood.
  • You can store the blank in a sealed bag or the freezer and finish the spoon after it dries.

Choose dry wood when

Dry wood is the practical choice when a store-bought blank is all you can get. None of the blanks in our spoon carving blanks guide is sold as green wood, so expect dry wood from a store.

  • You have no source of fresh wood and want to start today with a pre-cut blank.
  • The blank is a softer spoon wood. Paper birch is 910 lbf and black cherry 950 lbf dry, far easier than hard maple.
  • You want a practice or decorative spoon. Basswood at 410 lbf carves easily dry, but it dents and wears in daily use.
  • You want to finish in one sitting with no drying wait and little risk of cracks.

How to keep green wood from drying between sessions

Green wood starts to dry the moment it is cut, and it dries fastest from the end grain. Wood that dries too fast cracks. Coat the cut ends of a log with end sealer or latex paint right away, and keep it out of the sun.

Between sessions, put the blank or the half-carved spoon in a sealed plastic bag. For a longer break, put the bag in the freezer. David Fisher bags his roughed-out spoons and freezes them when there is room, which also keeps the wet wood from staining while it waits.

Note.Do not leave a half-carved green spoon on a sunny windowsill or near a heater. Fast, uneven drying is the standard cause of cracks.

Spoon carving with dry wood: how to make it workable

Start with the species. Pick the softest closed-grain hardwood you can find in the wood for carving chart and leave oak and ash aside: their large open pores make them a poor choice for an eating spoon, green or dry.

Then the edge. Dry wood shows a dull knife at once, so strop the knife as soon as it starts to drag. Take thin slices and small bites with the hook knife. If the surface still feels too hard, mist it with about half rubbing alcohol and half water. That is common carver practice, not a maker instruction. Soaking the whole blank is not standard, because it invites cracks as the wood dries again: see soaking wood before carving.

How long a green spoon takes to dry

A thin carved spoon dries in about 2 to 3 days, the figure Anne of All Trades gives for a spoon carved thin enough. David Fisher says a spoon can be ready for finish carving in a day or two and is certainly ready within a week. Other sources allow up to two weeks. A thick blank takes far longer than a spoon.

To slow the drying and lower the risk of cracks, put the spoon in a paper bag with a handful of its own shavings and keep it away from heat and sun. When it feels dry and warm to the touch, make the final cuts. Times for thicker pieces are in how to dry wood for carving.

Spoon cracked while drying? How to fix it →

Quick answers

Short answers to the searches behind this page. Each one follows the fact sheet for this site and the two spoon carvers listed under Sources.

  • Spoon carving wet or dry wood? Wet. Carve the spoon green, let it dry for about 2 to 3 days, then make the final cuts dry.
  • Can you carve spoons from green wood? Yes. It is the standard method, and green wood cuts far more easily than dry wood of the same species.
  • Spoon carving with dry wood? It works with a softer closed-grain wood, a freshly stropped edge and thin cuts. Expect more effort and more stropping.
  • Whittling green wood? Fine for spoons and simple shapes from a branch. Keep it bagged between sessions and dry the piece slowly to avoid cracks.

What you need for this

Sources