Tool
Wood for Carving Chart: Hardness by Species and What Each Wood Is Good For
Find your wood, or filter by the style you want to carve. Hardness is the Janka figure for dry wood. The verdicts follow the rule printed under the chart.
Short answer
Basswood is the standard answer: about 410 lbf on the Janka scale with a fine, even grain, good for whittling, chip carving and relief. Woods up to about 600 lbf whittle easily when dry. From about 600 to 1,050 lbf they are hard work dry and are usually carved green. Oak and ash are harder still and open-pored, and resinous pines and cedars are poor choices for spoons.
Where to start, by carving style
| Style | Start with | Also good | Skip at first |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whittling | basswood | butternut, eastern white pine, sugar pine, jelutong, red alder, European lime | oak, ash, hickory, southern yellow pine |
| Spoon carving | green birch or cherry | maple, walnut, alder, beech, apple, pear | pine, cedar, oak, ash |
| Chip carving | basswood | butternut, European lime | oak, hard maple, cedar, balsa |
| Relief carving | basswood | butternut, walnut, cherry, mahogany, European lime | balsa, southern yellow pine, hickory |
Wood for carving chart: 36 species
Have a piece of wood? Type its name. Want to carve a spoon or a chip carving board? Pick the style and the chart keeps the woods that suit it, softest first. The print button prints the whole chart, whatever is filtered on screen.
Carving style
Show
All 36 woods shown.
| Carved | Whittling | Spoon | Chip | Relief | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 67 to 70 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:No | |
Cuts with almost no force but crushes and fuzzes under anything less than a very sharp edge. Holds no detail. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. | ||||||
| 320 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Very soft and easy to work. Aromatic softwood, not for utensils. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: arborvitae. | ||||||
| 350 lbf | Either | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Maybe | |
Soft and easy to cut, but leaves fuzzy surfaces unless the edge is very sharp. Hardwood. Usually carved green or dry. Other names: aspen, poplar. | ||||||
| 350 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Easy to work but dents and scratches very easily. Strong aroma, not for utensils. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: cedar. | ||||||
| 380 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:No | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
The pine that carves: soft and even for a pine. Pick clear boards, knots and resin get in the way. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: white pine, pine. | ||||||
| 380 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:No | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Soft, even-textured white pine, easy to work with hand tools. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: pine. | ||||||
| 390 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Imported carving wood valued for softness, stability and ease of carving. Sold dry. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. | ||||||
| 410 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Yes | Relief:Yes | |
The standard carving wood: soft, fine, even texture, takes detail and paint. Too soft for a hard-wearing spoon. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: American linden, linden, lime. | ||||||
| 430 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Soft but stringy: poor machining characteristics and fuzzy surfaces. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: willow. | ||||||
| 430 lbf | Either | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Soft and easy to cut but fuzzy without a very sharp edge. Hardwood. Usually carved green or dry. Other names: cottonwood, poplar. | ||||||
| 490 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Yes | Relief:Yes | |
The usual second choice after basswood, with a visible grain. Can leave fuzzy surfaces, so keep the edge sharp. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: white walnut. | ||||||
| 510 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Soft conifer. Cypress knees are sold for carving. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: cypress. | ||||||
| 540 lbf | Either | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Very easy to work, a step harder than basswood. Soft for a spoon in daily use. Hardwood. Usually carved green or dry. Other names: tulip poplar, tulipwood, poplar. | ||||||
| 550 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Yes | |
An underrated carving wood that resists decay, suited to outdoor carvings. Coarse open grain limits fine detail. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. | ||||||
| 590 lbf | Green | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Very easy to work with hand tools, fine even grain. A common green spoon wood. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: alder. | ||||||
| 690 lbf | Dry | Whittling:No | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:No | |
Hard resinous bands alternate with soft ones and turn the edge aside. Longleaf pine is harder still, about 870 lbf. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: loblolly pine, shortleaf pine, yellow pine, pine. | ||||||
| 700 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
A soft maple: fine closed grain, much easier than hard maple. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: soft maple, maple. | ||||||
| 700 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Yes | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Yes | Relief:Yes | |
The classic European carving wood, rated among the most suitable for hand carving. Harder than American basswood. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: linden, limewood. | ||||||
| 800 to 900 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Listed for carving by the Wood Database and long used for relief work. Sold dry. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: mahogany, genuine mahogany. | ||||||
| 870 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Maybe | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Favored for wildfowl carving, takes fine detail and holds paint. Sold dry as carving blocks. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: tupelo. | ||||||
| 900 lbf | Dry | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Works easily apart from its many knots. Strong aroma, not for utensils. Softwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: aromatic red cedar, cedar. | ||||||
| 910 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Maybe | |
A standard green spoon wood. Wild grain can tear. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: white birch, birch. | ||||||
| 950 lbf | Either | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
One of the best all-round woods for workability. A favorite for spoons. Hardwood. Usually carved green or dry. Other names: cherry. | ||||||
| 950 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Fine closed grain, easier than hard maple. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: soft maple, maple. | ||||||
| 1,010 lbf | Either | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Crisp cuts and a dark color. A hard push for a knife when dry. Hardwood. Usually carved green or dry. Other names: walnut. | ||||||
| 1,020 lbf | Either | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:Maybe | Relief:Yes | |
Very fine, even grain that takes and holds crisp detail. Hardwood. Usually carved green or dry. Other names: holly. | ||||||
| 1,210 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Hard closed-grain birch, a standard green spoon wood. Whittle it green. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: European birch, birch. | ||||||
| 1,220 to 1,290 lbf | Dry | Whittling:No | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Hard, with large open pores. Carved with gouges and a mallet, not with a whittling knife. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: red oak, oak. | ||||||
| 1,260 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Hard closed-grain birch. Whittle it green. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: birch. | ||||||
| 1,300 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Hard, closed grain. One of the usual spoon woods. Carve it green. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: beech. | ||||||
| 1,320 lbf | Dry | Whittling:No | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Hard and ring-porous with large open pores. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: ash. | ||||||
| 1,350 to 1,360 lbf | Dry | Whittling:No | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Hard, with very large pores in the early wood. Mallet tools only. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: oak. | ||||||
| 1,450 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Durable closed-grain spoon wood. Heavy work even when green. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: sugar maple, rock maple, maple. | ||||||
| 1,660 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:No | Relief:Yes | |
Fine, even grain with no visible pores, easy to work for its hardness. Hardwood. Usually carved green. | ||||||
| 1,730 lbf | Green | Whittling:Maybe | Spoon:Yes | Chip:No | Relief:Maybe | |
Dense and hard. Carve it green. Hardwood. Usually carved green. Other names: applewood. | ||||||
| 1,820 to 1,880 lbf | Dry | Whittling:No | Spoon:No | Chip:No | Relief:No | |
Among the hardest common woods. Not a hand carving wood. Hardwood. Usually carved dry. Other names: hickory. | ||||||
Janka hardness in lbf for dry wood, at 12% moisture. A range means two sources differ. Click a row for its note. Spoon, Chip and Relief stand for spoon carving, chip carving and relief carving. Verdicts follow the rule printed under the chart, not tests.
How to read the chart
Janka hardness is the force, in pounds-force (lbf), needed to press a 0.444 inch steel ball halfway into the wood, measured at 12% moisture. A lower number cuts more easily. The figures are typical values and vary from one sample to the next. They describe dry wood: green wood of the same species cuts far more easily, which is why the harder spoon woods are carved fresh.
Each figure is the one on the species page of the Wood Database. Where the Janka table on Wikipedia, whose figures are of USDA origin, gives a different number, the row shows the range between the two. That is the case for balsa, Honduran mahogany, northern red oak, white oak and shagbark hickory. The bar under each number is the hardness on a scale that ends at 2,000 lbf.
The rule behind yes, maybe and no
- Whittling means a dry block held in the hand and cut with a knife. Yes: up to about 600 lbf and known to cut cleanly. Maybe: up to 600 lbf with a drawback (fuzzy, crushes, dents, coarse grain) or a softwood other than the two white pines, or 600 to about 1,050 lbf, or a harder closed-grain wood that is normally whittled green. No: ring-porous hardwoods above 1,050 lbf and pine with hard resinous bands. One override: European lime is a yes at 700 lbf because the Wood Database rates it among the most suitable woods for hand carving.
- Spoon carving means a spoon to eat or cook with, normally carved green. Yes: closed-grain hardwoods from about 590 lbf up. Maybe: hardwoods under 590 lbf, which carve easily but dent and wear, and woods normally sold only as dry carving stock (tupelo, mahogany). No: softwoods (resin or strong smell), balsa, and ring-porous hardwoods with large open pores (oak, ash, hickory, catalpa).
- Chip carving means a flat dry board and a chip carving knife. Yes: the three standard chip carving woods (basswood, butternut, European lime). Maybe: other even-grained hardwoods from 350 to about 1,050 lbf and the two soft white pines. No: everything else, including stringy willow and cottonwood, coarse-grained catalpa, the other softwoods and anything above 1,050 lbf.
- Relief carving means gouges on a clamped board, pushed by hand or struck with a mallet. Yes: hardwoods up to about 1,050 lbf that cut cleanly, the two white pines, and pear. Maybe: fuzzy or stringy woods (aspen, willow, cottonwood), paper birch (wild grain), softwoods other than the two white pines, and woods above 1,050 lbf, which call for a mallet. No: balsa, southern yellow pine, hickory.
Note.Verdicts follow the rule above. They are the usual hobby consensus applied to hardness and grain, not the result of testing. The no for oak and ash under spoon carving is about their open pores and common practice only.
The chart has no toxicity or allergy column. For dust and allergy questions see the Wood Database chart of wood allergies and toxicity.
Short answers
Can you whittle pine?
Eastern white pine and sugar pine, yes. Southern yellow pine and most construction lumber, no. More in can you whittle pine.
Can you whittle oak?
Not with a knife: oak runs 1,220 to 1,360 lbf and is open-pored. Oak is carved with gouges and a mallet.
Is cedar good for carving?
Cedar is soft enough but dents and is strongly aromatic. Not for spoons.
Is maple good for spoon carving?
Yes, carved green. The soft maples, silver and red (700 to 950 lbf), are easier than hard maple (1,450 lbf).
Is birch good for spoon carving?
Yes, birch is a standard green spoon wood.
Is poplar good for carving?
Yellow poplar is workable, a step harder than basswood, and soft for a spoon in daily use.
Read next
Sources
Hardness figures and working notes: the Wood Database, species pages and its Janka hardness article. Second figures for the ranges: the table in Wikipedia's Janka hardness test article. Wood varies from piece to piece, so treat every figure as typical, not exact.