Comparison
Whittling vs Wood Carving: What Is the Difference
Published
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
New to Prime? Try Prime free for fast, free shipping on eligible items.
Short answer
Whittling is one kind of wood carving: the wood is held in the hand and cut with a knife only. Wood carving is the broad word and also covers work with gouges, chisels, V-tools and a mallet on a clamped piece. Chip carving, relief carving and carving in the round are styles of wood carving. Whittling needs the fewest tools: one knife, a block of basswood and a strop.
Gear for this job
All 7 picks comparedFlexcut KN13 detail knife, 1.5 in blade
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonBeaverCraft C4s sloyd knife, 3 in, with sheath
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonMorakniv 106 wood carving knife, 3.25 in blade
See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
The two words are often used as if they meant the same thing, and for a small knife-cut figure they do overlap. The difference matters when you buy tools, because each style needs different ones, a different shape of wood and a different place to work. The table below compares the four styles people ask about, plus spoon carving. Prices are left out: what decides the cost of starting is the number of tools, so the last column lists the least you need to begin.
Whittling vs wood carving styles compared
Each row is one style. Read across for the tools, the wood it is usually cut from, where the work is done and the least you need to begin. Basswood, at 410 lbf on the Janka hardness scale, is the standard first wood in every dry-wood row. Other species are rated style by style in the wood for carving chart.
| Style | Tools | Wood | Workspace | To start you need |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whittling | One knife: a whittling knife or a locking pocket knife | Dry basswood block, held in the hand | A chair. No bench or clamp | Knife, basswood blocks, strop, glove for the holding hand |
| Chip carving | Chip carving cutting knife, sometimes a stab knife | Flat dry basswood board. 3/8 inch boards are sold for practice | A table, or a board on the lap | Knife, board, pencil and ruler, strop |
| Relief carving | Gouges, chisel and V-tool, pushed by hand or struck with a mallet | Flat board of basswood or butternut, clamped down | A bench or table with a clamp | A small gouge set, a clamp, strops for flat and curved edges |
| Carving in the round | A knife for small figures. Gouges and a mallet for larger pieces | A block, basswood first | The hand for small pieces, a bench and a hold-down for large ones | The whittling kit for small figures, a gouge set beyond that |
| Spoon carving | Straight (sloyd) knife and hook knife | Green closed-grain hardwood such as birch or cherry | The hand and the lap | Sloyd knife, hook knife, a green blank, strop |
Is whittling the same as wood carving?
Not quite. Every whittler is carving wood, but not all wood carving is whittling. Whittling means a knife only, with the wood held in the hand. Once the piece is clamped to a bench and shaped with gouges, chisels or a mallet, carvers call it wood carving. The words 'carving knife' on their own do not help: to most people that is a meat knife, so tool listings say whittling knife or wood carving knife.
The finished object does not decide the name. A small bird cut entirely with a knife is whittled. The same bird roughed out with a gouge and finished with a knife is carved. The line is drawn by the tools and by how the wood is held, not by the subject.
Choose whittling when
Whittling is the lightest way in. It suits anyone who wants to carve in an armchair, on a porch or on a trip, with almost nothing to carry and nothing to set up.
- You want to start with one tool. A fixed-blade whittling knife or a pocket knife with a locking blade is enough.
- You have no bench. The wood is held in the hand, so there is nothing to clamp.
- You want small figures, animals and simple shapes from a block that fits the hand.
- You are happy with soft dry wood. Woods up to about 600 lbf whittle well dry: basswood, butternut, eastern white pine.
Choose wood carving with gouges when
Gouges earn their place when the knife runs out of reach or force. A gouge cuts a hollow in one pass where a straight blade can only take small slices, and a mallet drives an edge through wood that is too hard to push by hand. Sweeps and widths are explained in the gouge sizes chart.
- You want pictures or lettering on a flat panel. That is relief carving, done with gouges and a V-tool on a clamped board.
- You want to carve harder woods. Walnut and cherry are relief woods, and oak, above about 1,050 lbf, is carved with gouges and a mallet, not with a whittling knife.
- You want pieces larger than a hand can hold. Clamped work leaves both hands on the tool, behind the edge.
- You are ready to learn sweep numbers and to sharpen curved edges, which takes slip stones or a shaped strop.
Chip carving vs whittling and relief carving
Chip carving decorates a flat board. The knife is held at about 65 degrees to the surface, and three cuts that meet at one point free a triangular chip. Rows of chips build borders and rosettes. Nothing is shaped in three dimensions, and that is the difference from whittling: a whittler carves a form out of a block, a chip carver cuts a pattern into a surface. The cuts are shown in how to chip carve.
Chip carving vs relief carving: both start from a flat board. Chip carving removes small geometric chips with one knife and leaves the surface between them untouched. Relief carving lowers the background with gouges so that a picture stands up from it, with rounded, modeled forms. Chip carving needs a knife and a ruler. Relief carving needs a set of gouges and a way to hold the board down.
Whittling vs carving in the round
Carving in the round means a figure finished on all sides and free-standing, as opposed to relief, which is seen from the front. The term describes the result, not the tool. A whittled figure is carved in the round with a knife. A larger sculpture is carved in the round with gouges and a mallet. So the two are not opposites: whittling is the knife-only way of carving in the round at hand size.
Which should a beginner start with?
Start with whittling if you have no tools: it needs one knife, and it teaches grain direction and sharpening from the first block. Start with chip carving if you like drawing patterns and working at a table. Move to relief carving when you want pictures in a panel and are ready to buy and sharpen gouges. Start with spoon carving if you can get green wood, because spoon woods are cut fresh.
Whatever the style, the first dry wood is basswood, and the edge is kept up on a strop, not on a stone. If you plan to whittle with a knife you already own, check that the blade locks: see whittling with a pocket knife. For a first spoon, how to carve a spoon lists the steps and the tools.
Note.A cut-resistant glove on the holding hand and a thumb guard on the knife hand are standard for knife work. They reduce slicing cuts. They are not cut-proof and do not stop the point of a knife.
Quick answers
Short answers to the comparison questions people search for. All of them come down to which tools are used and how the wood is held.
- Is whittling the same as wood carving? Whittling is a kind of wood carving done with a knife only, wood in the hand. Wood carving also covers gouges, chisels and mallet work.
- Chip carving vs whittling: what is the difference? Chip carving cuts triangular chips into a flat board to make a pattern. Whittling shapes a block into a form.
- Chip carving vs relief carving? Chip carving uses one knife and geometric chips. Relief carving uses gouges to lower a background so that a picture stands out.
- Is whittling carving in the round? Usually yes: a whittled figure is finished on all sides. Carving in the round can also be done with gouges, at any size.
What you need for this
- See price on AmazonAmazon
Flexcut KN13 detail knife, 1.5 in blade
From Best Whittling Knife for Beginners: Fixed-Blade Carvers Compared
- See price on AmazonAmazon
Flexcut KN15 chip carving knife, 1 in blade
From Best Chip Carving Knives: Cutting Knife, Stab Knife and Starter Sets
- See price on AmazonAmazon
Flexcut FR405 deluxe palm gouge set, 9 tools
From Best Wood Carving Gouge Sets: Palm Tools for Hand Carving
- See price on AmazonAmazon
BeaverCraft BW19 Basswood Carving Blocks
From Best Basswood Carving Blocks: Sizes, Pack Counts and Price per Block